Toni didn’t know if he was gay or not, so I put him to a test, and it turns out he likes pussy.
I’d known Toni for over a year now, since he moved in to the house across the street and turns out our parents had known each other for many years, and we became good friends, we are both 12, I am a few months older than Toni though, not that it’s relevant.
The thing about Toni is that he liked to dress in strange clothes, he would even wear skirts sometimes, always wearing make-up and he has long hair that he often had coloured with highlights, almost from the first day I met him I thought he was gay, even my parents told me he was gay.
But as time went on I started to notice things, like the fact that I never saw him with another boy, could have been because all the boys at school were cruel and made fun of him, I started to have flashbacks of our time together when we went in to town and stuff, and I couldn’t remember a single time when I saw him talking to another boy or flirting with another boy, he was always hanging around with me and my girl friends, a bit strange for someone who is gay.
His sexual preference wasn’t something he liked to talk about much, he’d often go quiet, change the subject or make excuses and leave whenever I brought it up, but I decided I was going to confront him about it, it just so happened that he was sleeping over at my house, our parents didn’t mind that we shared a bed, they thought he was gay so assumed nothing would happen, how wrong they were.
We were laying in my bed under the covers and we’d turned the light out about 10 minutes prior, but I couldn’t sleep, it was nagging at me and I had to ask him, so I turned on the bedside lamp and turned to face him, I just stared at his face for a little while in silence.
“Why are you staring at me?” he asked.
“Are you gay?” I just came out and said, no messing around, I felt our friendship was strong enough for me to just come out and ask him directly.
“What?” he chuckled, and looking a little embarrassed.
“Are you gay?” I asked again.
“Yeah.” He replied.
“Then why have I never seen you with a boyfriend, I’ve never seen you flirting with another boy, and you don’t hang out with any of them.” I said.
“I do talk to boys.” He replied, defensively.
“Who? – Who do you talk too?” I asked.
“Carl – and – Liam.” He replied.
“Carl’s got a girlfriend, he isn’t gay, and Liam’s 8 years old – and your cousin.” I said, I knew he was just trying to think of boys I’d seen him talk too, but they didn’t count.
“I don’t know – why does it matter?” he asked.
“Because I want to know.” I said.
“Know what?” he asked.
“Are you gay?” I asked.
“Yeah.” He replied, sternly.
“I don’t believe you.” I replied, I decided to try an experiment and see what happened, I pushed my hand down the front of his pyjama bottoms and gripped his cock in my hand.
“Sarah! What the fuck are you doing?” he asked, looking very surprised at my actions.
“Are you gay?” I asked him again.
“Yes!” he replied with a chuckle and look of bemusement on his face.
“Then why is your cock getting hard.” I said, with a light giggle, feeling it growing and swelling inside my grip.
“Because you’re touching it.” He replied.
“But if you were gay then you wouldn’t get turned on by a girl touching you.” I replied, I didn’t know if my point was valid or not, he tried pulling my hand out of his bottoms, but I was gripping his cock tightly and all it did was make me tug on his cock as he pulled on my arm, “I’m not letting go.” I giggled.
“Oh my God, please let go of my dick.” He said.
“Not until I know.” I said.
“Know what?” he asked, looking confused.
“Are you gay?” I asked.
“I don’t know.” He replied, finally the first answer he had given that I actually believed.
“You don’t know if you’re gay or not. Do you like boys or girls more?” I asked.
He shrugged his shoulders at me.
I was secretly enjoying holding his now rock hard cock in my hand, and it made my panties get wet, I was totally turned on by him all of a sudden, and I had started to gently rub and tug on his long shaft beneath his bottoms, “Do you want to fuck?” I said, I was thinking it and for some reason the words just came out of my mouth.
He looked at me with shock, “What!?” he uttered.
“Yeah – Yeah let’s do it. Do you want to try it? – then you’ll know if you like girls or not.” I said, I was surprised with my own sudden confidence, I had never thought about having sex before, certainly not with Toni, but now it was all I could think about and I was well up for doing it, I released his cock and then rolled on to my back and quickly pulled my panties off from under my night shirt, “Lets do it. Come on.” I said.
“I don’t know how.” He said.
“Neither do I. We’ll figure it out.” I replied.
“Okay.” He said, swallowing a lump in his throat as he stared down at me fully exposed pussy.
I helped him take his bottoms off and he rubbed his hand gently over my pussy whilst I continued to rub his hard cock.
“It feels weird.” He said, commenting on how my pussy felt to touch.
“So does your cock.” I giggled.
After a little while he laid on top of me and we ended up kissing for ages while rubbing each other’s privates.
“Do I just rub it over it.” He asked, not knowing what to do, not that I knew any better either.
“I think you’re meant to put it inside it.” I said.
“Where?” he asked, looking down on my pussy and both of us wondering where his cock should go.
I literally took matters in to my own hands, and by matters I mean his cock, and I sort of guided it on to my pussy, then I rubbed his tip up and down my crack until it slipped between my flaps and I felt it hit a tender spot, “There. I think there. Push.” I said.
He pushed his hips forward and his cock dug in to my pussy, I could feel my hymen being pushed inward, he was definitely in the right place and it hurt a little and made me gasp, “Ungh.”, “Keep pushing.” I said, the pain got more and more intense and then my hymen tore and I felt his cock go inside of me, “Ooah – Ung! – Ooh.”
“I think it’s in.” he gasped.
“Yeah – definitely in.” I replied.
Every time his cock moved, even just a millimetre, it drove me crazy, it hurt but it also send a very pleasurable buzz up my entire body, “Ooh – Ungh” I moaned every time it moved in my hole and very slowly went deeper inside of me.
We got the hang of it pretty quickly and soon he was thrusting it in and out of me faster, “This feels nice. Do you like it?” He said.
“Oh my God – Ungh” I moaned.
“Are you okay?” he asked, pausing his thrusting.
“Don’t stop! – Oh my God!” I moaned.
He continued, and I just loved every second of it, the feel of his hard cock sliding in and out of my pussy, stimulating every single pleasure sensor in my body, I didn’t know if we were doing it right or not, but damn it was go good, “Ungh”, I honestly never felt so much joy before, “Oh my God – Ungh – Ungh!” I moaned.
I heard my mom bang on the bedroom wall and tell us to be quiet, “Sorry, mom.” I shouted back, luckily she didn’t suspect that we were actually having sex, then I picked up my panties and shoved them in my mouth to keep myself quiet, I couldn’t control my moans, they just came out.
Toni wanted to stop but I wouldn’t let him, I clamped my feet around him and forced him to thrust his cock back inside me, and thankfully he continued and he fucked me real good.
Then he made me laugh, because I felt his cock swelling up inside me as he ejaculated, and he started to groan out loud, so I had to put my hand over his mouth quickly to keep him quiet, I felt him ejaculate inside me, I could feel the warm liquid drowning my cervix as his swelling cock pushed against my inner walls.
He went limp on top of me and we just laughed and giggled, it was so much fun having sex together, we couldn’t believe that we’d actually done it.
Eventually I caught my breath and I asked him again, “So, are you gay?” I asked.
He shook his head and smiled, “No.” he replied.
“Do you like girls then?” I asked.
“Yeah.” He replied, nodding repeatedly.
I finally found out that Toni wasn’t gay, he just liked being feminine, which was perfectly fine, at least he was comfortable and able to express himself, we became boyfriend and girlfriend after that night, of course we kept that a secret, we couldn’t let our parents find out he wasn’t gay or we wouldn’t be able to share a bed together anymore.
This story isn’t about being against gay people, I like gay people, and people are allowed to love who they want, this story was about me and my friend Toni who was unsure about his sexuality, but I soon sorted that out.
I love Toni, and his big hard cock.